Cornell professor Joseph Margulies discusses the upcoming retrial of Lindsay Clancy, who killed her three children, and the choice prosecutors face between asking what she did and asking what happened. Professor Margulies argues that prosecutors should ask the second question, because understanding the full context of Clancy’s life and decline is the only way to see the truth and judge her with compassion rather than as a monster.
UC Davis law professor Vikram David Amar discusses the federal government’s recent efforts, through litigation and threats of prosecution, to pressure California and Washington election officials over alleged noncitizen voting. Professor Amar argues that the courts rightly rejected those efforts because voter eligibility is a matter of state law, and the federal government cannot commandeer state officials to enforce it more aggressively than their own reasonable enforcement discretion dictates.
University of Pennsylvania professor Marci A. Hamilton discusses how Congress should respond to the 2026 midterm elections, in which voters rejected the Trump administration’s and the Supreme Court’s efforts to remake the constitutional order. Professor Hamilton argues that the new Democratic majorities should prioritize restoring constitutional checks and balances by reining in the President and his Cabinet, confronting financial and moral corruption, and reforming the Supreme Court.
Cornell law professor Michael C. Dorf discusses whether the size of the Democrats’ new Senate majority matters, as races in Alaska and Mississippi remain uncalled. Professor Dorf argues that every seat counts, because a larger majority guards against defections, eases the path to the 60 votes needed to break a filibuster, and cushions the party against future electoral losses.
Amherst professor Austin Sarat discusses a Reuters/Ipsos poll showing that many Americans support or are open to a second attempt to execute Christa Pike after Tennessee’s failed execution. Professor Sarat argues that this support reflects ignorance of the suffering failed executions inflict, and that fully informed Americans would reject a second attempt as offensive to human dignity.
Amherst professor Austin Sarat discusses the history of public executions in America in light of Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s scrapped plan to livestream the execution of Nidal Hasan. Professor Sarat argues that the plan, though stopped, reflects the Trump administration’s contempt for the American public, which it treats as a prop for its displays of cruelty.
Amherst College professor Austin Sarat discusses Florida Governor Ron DeSantis’s record-setting pace of executions, using the scheduled November 5 execution of Jesse Guardado to examine DeSantis’s refusal to grant clemency, his sole control over death warrants, and Florida’s history of wrongful death sentences. Professor Sarat argues that DeSantis has turned capital punishment into cruel, arbitrary assembly-line justice that ignores remorse and rehabilitation, disregards the risk of executing the innocent, and serves his political ends.
UC Davis Law professor Vikram David Amar discusses the Ninth Circuit’s recent decision in United States v. California, which held that the federal government is certain to succeed in its Supremacy Clause challenge to California’s “No Vigilantes Act” (SB 805), a law requiring non-uniformed law enforcement officers, including federal immigration agents, to display identification while on duty. Professor Amar praises the panel for recognizing that a state law directly regulating federal officers on the job is invalid absent federal assent, however small or evenhanded its burden, but argues that the court’s attempt to distinguish the traffic-law dicta in Johnson v. Maryland was unpersuasive and that the better explanation may lie in historical evidence of federal assent.
In the second installment of a two-part column, University of Pennsylvania professor Marci A. Hamilton discusses the Catholic Nationalists who have joined the push for theocracy in the United States, focusing on the postliberal, or integralist, theorists led by Patrick Deneen and Adrian Vermeule and on Opus Dei and its allies, including Leonard Leo, Vice President JD Vance, and the architects of Project 2025. Professor Hamilton argues that these movements seek to impose Catholic natural law on Americans through an authoritarian elite, that they wrongly cast the many religious Americans who disagree with them as secular, that integralism has repeatedly failed elsewhere, and that because both groups need an authoritarian at the top, theocracy is on the ballot this fall.
UC Davis Law professor Vikram David Amar discusses the federal government’s lawsuit seeking an emergency injunction to bar California election officials from counting federal ballots cast next month by about 20,000 individuals the United States suspects are noncitizens, situating it among the Trump administration’s broader efforts to intervene in state administration of the midterm elections. Professor Amar argues that the suit is likely to fail because the federal ban on noncitizen voting can rest only on Congress’ immigration power, which the anti-commandeering principle of New York v. United States and Printz v. United States limits, so the federal government cannot compel California to investigate and set aside suspected noncitizens’ ballots, and neither its preemption nor its aiding-and-abetting theory, nor the request for relief so close to an election, changes that result.
In the first installment of a two-part column, University of Pennsylvania professor Marci A. Hamilton discusses how the 2026 midterm election will test the religious identity of the United States, focusing on the White Evangelical Christian Nationalists who claim America is a “Christian country” and their growing influence in the Trump Administration through figures like Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, Project 2025, and allied groups such as the Alliance Defending Freedom. Professor Hamilton argues that these nationalists rely on a revisionist history that erases the nation’s founding religious diversity, that the Supreme Court’s conservative majority and a compliant Republican Congress have helped them pursue theocracy without amending the Constitution, and that because most Americans reject Christian Nationalism, voters should use the midterms to stop it.
Cornell Law professor Michael C. Dorf discusses the Supreme Court’s new Term, which looks relatively quiet, and the major legal changes the conservative supermajority has already made. Professor Dorf argues that the Court has largely finished dismantling the liberal-era precedents it targeted, leaving few blockbuster cases, though future changes depend on who appoints the next Justices.
Amherst professor Austin Sarat discusses President Trump’s authorization of a firing-squad execution for Nidal Hasan, the first U.S. military execution since 1961, placing it within the history of military executions, the current military death row, and Secretary Hegseth’s push to revive the practice. Professor Sarat argues that reviving military executions reflects a cruelty-focused “warrior ethos” that departs from the modern military’s tradition of mercy, and that it will damage the teamwork and community on which military effectiveness depends.
Amherst professor Austin Sarat discusses the botched lethal injection of Christa Pike in Tennessee in the context of America’s long history of failed executions and court rulings allowing states to try again. Professor Sarat argues that Pike’s case is unlikely to end lethal injection because states rarely abandon an execution method after it fails, and switching methods is costly and no guarantee of improvement.
Amherst professor Austin Sarat discusses Judge Timothy Kelly’s temporary restraining order requiring President Donald Trump to restore the White House press credentials of CNN, MS NOW, and Politico reporters. Professor Sarat argues that the White House revoked the passes over negative coverage, that its national security justification was a sham, and that Kelly correctly applied binding precedent requiring due process before a press pass is revoked.
Cornell Law professor Michael C. Dorf discusses the U.S. Civil Rights Commission’s final report on the federal response to campus antisemitism, examining both its bipartisan findings and the separate commissioner statements urging it to go further. Professor Dorf argues that the report’s nuanced approach—acknowledging administrators’ genuine difficulty balancing free speech with antidiscrimination law while criticizing the Trump administration’s pretextual and legally flawed enforcement efforts—is justified, and that calls for a broader scope or a formal antisemitism definition would be legally and practically misguided.
University of Pennsylvania professor Marci A. Hamilton discusses how child sex abuse and the Epstein files could affect the midterm elections, focusing on Republican candidates and on Pennsylvania’s failure to pass a law letting past abuse victims sue. Professor Hamilton argues that voters of both parties want powerful people held accountable, and that Republican leaders who ignore survivors will lose votes.
UC Davis Law professor Vikram David Amar discusses the U.S. Supreme Court’s third rejection of Republican officials’ attempts to use Missouri’s 2025 redistricting map (HB1) for the 2026 congressional election, situating the ruling within the broader national redistricting conflict and analyzing what it reveals about the Court’s emergency docket practices. Professor Amar argues that the decision undercuts claims that the Court’s shadow docket favors Trump, demonstrates the Court’s insistence that lower federal courts respect its prior rulings and state supreme court authority under Rooker-Feldman and Moore v. Harper, and shows the Justices applying the Purcell doctrine while placing blame for the electoral confusion squarely on Missouri’s Republican Secretary of State rather than on the state courts.
UC Davis Law professor Vikram David Amar discusses the Eighth Circuit’s latest ruling reinstating Missouri's Republican-drawn HB1 congressional maps for the 2026 election, examining how this decision fits into the ongoing legal battle following the Supreme Court's September 10 stay of a similar lower court order. Professor Amar argues that the Eighth Circuit's ruling is legally untenable because it contradicts the Supreme Court’s implicit merits assessment from September 10 and violates the Purcell doctrine’s prohibition on late judicial interference with elections already underway, leading him to predict the Supreme Court will again intervene to block HB1’s maps from being used in November.
UNLV Boyd School of Law professor Leslie C. Griffin discusses St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy, a Supreme Court case about whether Colorado can deny state funding to Catholic schools that want to exclude LGBTQ students and families while still receiving public money. Professor Griffin argues that religious freedom does not entitle schools to violate neutral antidiscrimination laws, and that the Court should reject any rule that would let religious institutions get paid to discriminate.











































